Bigon's blog

Aller au contenu | Aller au menu | Aller à la recherche

Mot-clé - belgique

Fil des billets - Fil des commentaires

dimanche, février 21 2010

Hadopi made in Belgium

hadopimayo.pngThe Belgian senator Philippe Monfils (MR) has presented a few weeks ago a project (in french) for a HADOPI-like[1] law in Belgium. This law aims at condemning people who share copyrighted works without going to court. If an internet user's connexion is used for illegal filesharing, she will first receive a warning, then a fine. The third step proposes a limitation of bandwidth. The last one is the complete suppression of that person's internet connection (but she still has to pay for that connection).

In the facts this arises a lot of questions and fears about the freedom to access the Internet but also about the means used to prove the facts. An IP address isn't enough to prove anything, considering how easy it is to break into a WiFi access point, even a secured one. It also raises the problem of the conviction that will affect a group of people (whole families, businesses,...) for the crime of a single person. There is also a chances of double penalty (the obligation to continue to pay the fees for a suspended Internet access) and there is also the possibility that somebody gets convicted for counteracting while his neighbour only gets a warnings for the same infraction and thus breaking an equal justice.

Also, will such a law really help artists (or the entertainment industry)? There is no proof that it will encourage people to buy more discs and moreover how can anybody buy anything from legal sources without an internet access?

What is sure is that this will cost lot of money for results that are not proven.

Hadopi Mayonnaise is a group of concerned citizens that want to open the dialogue about this law. If you want to help them you can visit NURPA[2] website. They are currently looking for translation for both websites in Dutch.

Notes

[1] HADOPI is the name of the law that has made lot of noises in France

[2] the association behind Hadopi Mayonnaise

mardi, avril 1 2008

MoBIB ou comment la STIB va tracer ses voyageurs?

MobibA partir de 2009 la STIB va passer à un nouveau système de titre de transport appelé MoBIB. MoBIB est une carte RFID qui permettra de centraliser les différents titres de transport et abonnements dans la capitale. Si le but est louable (simplification pour les voyageurs et impacte écologique) une question se pose cependant, la STIB va-t-elle pouvoir suivre ses voyageurs?

À première vue, la carte semble nominative (ce sera d'office le cas pour les abonnements). À chaque compostage, le lecteur RFID aurait la capacité d'enregistrer le numéro de la puce et il serait possible (sans trop d'effort) d'obtenir l'identité de la personne. Actuellement avec les cartes jetables il serait également possible à la STIB de faire le même genre de chose mais dans une moindre mesure car par définition une carte jetable est non-nominative... et jetable.

La question est donc, que va enregistrer la STIB? la police aura-t-elle accès aux informations, combien de temps ces infos seront gardée, aucune réponse disponible sur le site de la STIB pour le moment

Edit: J'ai retiré le lien vers la STIB, car celle-ci ne veux pas d'hyperliens pointant vers son site sans son accord préalable.